Icon Icon
Icon
Free Shipping: US Orders $100+ 📦 International $300+ Free Shipping: US Orders $100+ 📦 International $300+
Bag (0) Close
Bag Crap Tag + Add Bag Crap Logo Charm?
+ Gift wrap your order for $8?
Order Note (Optional)
Total $0
Checkout
Your bag is empty
Shop All Shop All
Charm Packs Charm Packs
Vintage Keychains Vintage Keychains
Mini Bag Charms Mini Bag Charms
Plush Charms Plush Charms
Bag Chains Bag Chains
Hardware Hardware
Custom Orders Custom Orders
Blind Box Charms Blind Box Charms
Trending Trending
Deadstock Keychains Deadstock Keychains
Polly Pocket Polly Pocket
Food Charms Food Charms
Snoopy Snoopy
Hello Kitty Hello Kitty
Barbie Barbie
Beaded Charms Beaded Charms
Merch Merch
Trolls Trolls
Toggle View

Deadstock & New Old Stock Vintage Keychains (36)

RARE NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Chutes & Ladders RARE NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Chutes & Ladders
RARE NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Chutes & Ladders $50
🔍 🛒
RARE NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Super Soaker Squirt Gun RARE NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Super Soaker Squirt Gun
RARE NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Super Soaker Squirt Gun $75
🔍 🛒
NIB 1997 Vintage Keychain: The Butt-Head Bendable Keychain NIB 1997 Vintage Keychain: The Butt-Head Bendable Keychain
NIB 1997 Vintage Keychain: The Butt-Head Bendable Keychain $65
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Blue & White University Cheerleader Barbie NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Blue & White University Cheerleader Barbie
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Blue & White University Cheerleader Barbie $45
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Blonde Original Barbie NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Blonde Original Barbie
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Blonde Original Barbie Sold Out
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Blonde Solo in the Spotlight Barbie NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Blonde Solo in the Spotlight Barbie
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Blonde Solo in the Spotlight Barbie $45
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Brunette Solo in the Spotlight Barbie NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Brunette Solo in the Spotlight Barbie
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Brunette Solo in the Spotlight Barbie $45
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Wedding Day Barbie NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Wedding Day Barbie
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Wedding Day Barbie $45
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Picnic Barbie NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Picnic Barbie
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Picnic Barbie $45
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Brunette Original Barbie NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Brunette Original Barbie
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Brunette Original Barbie $45
🔍 🛒
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Trinklets Hello Kitty Tiny Sticker Case NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Trinklets Hello Kitty Tiny Sticker Case
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Trinklets Hello Kitty Tiny Sticker Case $45
🔍 🛒
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Jim Henson's Muppets Miss Piggy Tin NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Jim Henson's Muppets Miss Piggy Tin
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Jim Henson's Muppets Miss Piggy Tin $35
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Betty Boop NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Betty Boop
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Betty Boop $35
🔍 🛒
New
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Total Trollers, Yellow Hair Troll NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Total Trollers, Yellow Hair Troll
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Total Trollers, Yellow Hair Troll $65
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Barbie NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Barbie
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Barbie "Lights N' Sounds" Micro Electronics $45
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Barbie NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Barbie
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Barbie "Lights N' Sounds" Micro Electronics $45
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: The Game of Life NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: The Game of Life
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: The Game of Life $40
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: View Master NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: View Master
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: View Master $40
🔍 🛒
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Wheel of Fortune NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Wheel of Fortune
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Wheel of Fortune $35
🔍 🛒
Sale
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Don't Break the Ice Game NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Don't Break the Ice Game
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Don't Break the Ice Game $35 $30
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Get Smart Lunch Box NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Get Smart Lunch Box
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Get Smart Lunch Box $35
🔍 🛒
RARE Vintage 1996 Talkgirl Tiger Electronics Recorder Keychain NIB RARE Vintage 1996 Talkgirl Tiger Electronics Recorder Keychain NIB
RARE Vintage 1996 Talkgirl Tiger Electronics Recorder Keychain NIB $150
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Cracker Jack NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Cracker Jack
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Cracker Jack Sold Out
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Colorforms Brand NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Colorforms Brand
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Colorforms Brand $20
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Magna Doodle NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Magna Doodle
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Magna Doodle $40
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Ouija Board Game NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Ouija Board Game
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Ouija Board Game $40
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Barrel of Monkeys Game NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Barrel of Monkeys Game
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Barrel of Monkeys Game $30
🔍 🛒
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Fisher-Price Corn Popper NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Fisher-Price Corn Popper
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Fisher-Price Corn Popper $40
🔍 🛒
Sale
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: The Classic Tinkertoy Construction Set NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: The Classic Tinkertoy Construction Set
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: The Classic Tinkertoy Construction Set $20 $16
🔍 🛒
RARE NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Super Soaker RARE NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Super Soaker
RARE NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Super Soaker $75
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Tonka Mighty Construction NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Tonka Mighty Construction
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Tonka Mighty Construction $20
🔍 🛒
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Hasbro Candy Land NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Hasbro Candy Land
NIB Y2K Vintage Keychain: Hasbro Candy Land $40
🔍 🛒
RARE NIB Vintage 2003 Kirby Right Back At Ya! Keychain
RARE NIB Vintage 2003 Kirby Right Back At Ya! Keychain $55
🔍 🛒
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Koosh Bubble Gun NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Koosh Bubble Gun
NIB 90s Vintage Keychain: Koosh Bubble Gun $50
🔍 🛒
Vintage Powerpuff Girls Blossom Vintage Keychain - NIB Vintage Powerpuff Girls Blossom Vintage Keychain - NIB
Vintage Powerpuff Girls Blossom Vintage Keychain - NIB $39
🔍 🛒
Vintage NIB 90s Kermit The Frog Muppets In Space Plush Bag Charm Vintage NIB 90s Kermit The Frog Muppets In Space Plush Bag Charm Vintage NIB 90s Kermit The Frog Muppets In Space Plush Bag Charm
Vintage NIB 90s Kermit The Frog Muppets In Space Plush Bag Charm $62
🔍 🛒